The Question I Never Have to Ask
I bought a Headspace lifetime subscription in 2016. Ten years later, is it worth it? Why deciding once beats streaks, plus the story of Andy Puddicombe and Rich Pierson.
This week I went through my subscriptions. It is the kind of chore I put off until a renewal email forces my hand, and this time one did. I had a list of meditation apps to sort out: keep, cancel, keep, cancel.
Headspace wasn't on the list. It never is.
A decision made once
In 2016 I was living in New York, working in venture and moving fast. Headspace was still a young company then, and I was an early fan. I had been using it long enough to feel the difference on the days I sat versus the days I didn't. It wasn't dramatic. I was a little less reactive. A little quicker to notice when I was spinning.
So I bought the lifetime subscription. If I remember right, it was somewhere between $400 and $600. That felt like a lot of money for an app at the time. I remember hesitating over it. I also remember thinking that if I was going to spend money on something, I would rather spend it on my own head than on almost anything else.
Where it came from
Part of why I trusted it is the story behind it.
Headspace was started in London in 2010 by Andy Puddicombe and Rich Pierson. Andy is the voice. In 1994 he walked away from a sports science degree and went to Asia to train as a Buddhist monk. He spent about ten years in that life, studying in India, Nepal, Myanmar and Thailand, and was fully ordained at a Tibetan monastery in the Himalayas. He came back to the UK in 2004, and, in my favorite detail, went on to study circus arts in London while he built a small meditation practice.
Rich came from the business side. He was working in advertising in London, stressed and burned out, and Andy taught him to meditate. Rich helped Andy figure out how to bring it to more people. Before there was an app, they ran live meditation events in London and New York. The app came in 2012. They tell the whole story on NPR's How I Built This, and it is worth a listen.
That pairing is the whole thing for me. A monk who could explain an old practice in plain, kind English, and a marketer who could make it feel approachable instead of mystical. No robes, no incense, no pressure. Just a friendly guy with a British accent saying, it's fine, your mind wandered, come back.
Headspace has grown up a lot since then. It merged with a mental health company in 2021, and Andy and Rich have since stepped back from running it. But the voice in my ears most mornings is still his.
So, was a Headspace lifetime subscription worth it? It has turned out to be one of the best purchases I have ever made, and not really because of the price per year.
It's because I never have to decide again.
I don't get a renewal email asking whether it is still worth it. I don't sit there doing the math on how many sessions I used last month. That question just doesn't exist for me. The decision was made once, ten years ago, by a version of me who had already felt the benefit. I trust him on this one.
Stop keeping score on the things meant to help you
Do I meditate every day? No.
Do I get angry at myself when I miss? Also no.
I don't track streaks. I don't check whether I am using it enough. Some weeks I sit most mornings. Some weeks life gets loud and I don't. Then one morning I open it again, and it is right where I left it.
I think a lot of us turn the things that are supposed to help into one more thing to grade ourselves on. The meditation app becomes a scorecard. Miss a day and the streak resets, and now there is a small voice saying you failed at relaxing. That is a strange way to treat the thing that is supposed to quiet that voice.
Taking the scorekeeping away let the practice be what it is: something I come back to, not something I keep up.
Committing for the long haul
I see the opposite pattern all the time in work. A team tries a new tool, a new process, a new strategy, and three weeks later they are asking whether it's working. Then they switch. Then they ask again. Nothing gets the time it needs to actually work.
Some things only pay off over years. You have to decide up front that you are in it, and then stop re-deciding. Trusting the process is a lot easier when you have taken away the option to quit every month.
I don't think that means locking yourself into everything. It means finding a few things that have already earned your trust, and letting them be settled.
The simple part
The other thing I keep coming back to is how simple it is. Andy's voice. A short session. A course when I want to go deeper on something. A small idea that sticks with me through the day.
It doesn't try to do too much, and it has been there through New York, a move home to Cincinnati, a rebrand, a wedding and a lot of ordinary Tuesdays.
So, is Headspace worth it?
For me, yes. But to each their own.
I have tried and dabbled with just about all of them over the years. Other apps, other teachers, other styles. A lot of them are good. Some of them I still open now and then. But I keep coming back to this one, and I have stopped asking why. It fits how my head works.
If you are trying to decide, my only advice is this: don't pick the app with the best features. Pick the one whose voice you want to hear on a bad morning. Then give it more than a few weeks before you judge it. The practice does the work. The app just has to be something you will actually open.
With Thanksgiving next week, I have been thinking about what I am grateful for. Most of the list is people. But near the top of the rest is this: a few things in my life I don't have to question. They just stay.